Etsy vs Gumroad

Etsy vs Gumroad fees

Etsy Seller US (9.5% + $0.45) compared directly against Gumroad (12.9% + $0.80).

Rates verified Nov 17, 2026 Open Etsy calculator
Lower-fee winner
Etsy
Lower fee by $3.75/order
Monthly fee savings
$187.50
$2,250.00 saved per year
Etsy monthly fees
$497.50
Etsy · 9.95% effective
Gumroad monthly fees
$685.00
Gumroad · 13.70% effective

Configure transaction and plan matchup

Adjust order value and monthly volume

Etsy fee ledger

Daily or weekly (US ACH free)
Gross customer payment $100.00
Percentage fee (9.50%) -$9.50
Fixed per-order fee -$0.25
Per-item listing fee -$0.20
Total fees per order -$9.95
Net payout to US bank $90.05

Gumroad fee ledger

Weekly Friday (US ACH free)
Gross customer payment $100.00
Percentage fee (12.90%) -$12.90
Fixed per-order fee -$0.80
Total fees per order -$13.70
Net payout to US bank $86.30

Monthly cost curve: Etsy vs Gumroad ($500 to $50,000/mo)

Drop marketplace transaction cuts above $600/mo

Moving from 10%+ marketplaces to Shopify Basic ($39/mo + 2.9% + $0.30) turns cash-positive once monthly sales cross roughly $400–$600.

Partner note: FeeLedger may earn an affiliate referral fee if you open an account through this link.

Start Shopify US trial

Comparison questions & payout rules

US ACH settlement

Which is cheaper at $5,000/month: Etsy or Gumroad?

Across 50 orders of $100 ($5,000 gross), Etsy Seller US saves $187.50 per month ($2,250.00 per year) compared to Gumroad.

What are the base transaction fees for Etsy vs Gumroad?

Etsy (Standard Organic Sale) charges 9.50% + $0.45, while Gumroad (Direct Link Sale (10% + $0.50 + Card)) charges 12.90% + $0.80.

Is there a monthly revenue break-even point between Etsy and Gumroad?

At an average $100 order size, one option remains consistently cheaper from $100 up to $500,000/month because neither relies on a higher monthly base fee offsetting a lower rate.

Do both Etsy and Gumroad pay out to a US bank ACH account?

Yes. Both platforms support USD payouts to US checking accounts via ACH (Etsy: Daily or weekly (US ACH free); Gumroad: Weekly Friday (US ACH free)).